TL;DR
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The Kitchn’s Ali Domrongchai tested 12 frozen breakfast sandwiches from five brands over a week and named Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese the closest match to McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. At the prices she reported, a four-pack cost $8, compared with $4.89 for one McDonald’s sandwich; the result reflects one reviewer’s taste test, not a broader product study.
The Kitchn food editor Ali Domrongchai has named Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese her preferred frozen substitute for a McDonald’s Egg McMuffin after tasting 12 sandwiches from five brands over one week. The comparison also found a marked price difference at the prices she paid: an $8 four-pack of Jimmy Dean sandwiches versus $4.89 for one McDonald’s sandwich.
Domrongchai reported that the Jimmy Dean sandwich came closest to the McDonald’s version among the frozen options she tried. Both have an English muffin, egg, cheddar cheese and sausage, though the sandwiches are not identical. The Jimmy Dean sausage includes chicken, according to the report, and its egg is a scrambled disk; the McDonald’s sandwich uses a whole egg with a hard yolk.
The reviewer said she found the frozen sandwich less greasy while still enjoying its flavor. She described the sausage as juicy, the reheated egg as soft and the cheese as gooey and sharp. Those observations are her personal tasting assessment, not laboratory findings or a formal nutritional comparison.
At the listed prices, the Jimmy Dean package works out to $2 per sandwich, before any applicable tax. Domrongchai reported paying $4.89 for the McDonald’s Egg McMuffin and $7.29 for a meal that included a hash brown and coffee. Prices can vary by store and location, and the article says its prices were accurate when it was published.
A Lower-Cost Freezer Option
The comparison gives readers a practical reference point for choosing between a restaurant breakfast and a supermarket freezer option. Based on the reported prices, buying Jimmy Dean’s four-pack costs less per sandwich than ordering one Egg McMuffin, while also allowing the buyer to keep several breakfasts at home. That may suit people seeking a quick meal without a restaurant stop.
The cost comparison has limits: it is based on the prices Domrongchai encountered, and the McDonald’s meal price includes coffee and a hash brown while the $4.89 figure is for the sandwich alone. The piece does not compare serving sizes, nutrition, or the full cost of preparing the frozen product. Its central finding is about one reviewer’s taste preference and the prices she found, rather than evidence that every customer will prefer the frozen sandwich.
Jimmy Dean frozen breakfast sandwiches
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Sandwiches Compared
Domrongchai said she set out to find a convenient stand-in for an Egg McMuffin, which she described as a familiar favorite but one she did not want to pay roughly $4 to $5 for each time. She spent a week eating a dozen breakfast sandwiches across five brands. The supplied report does not list every product or provide scores for all of them, so the account supports a winner from her test but not a full ranking of the options.
The Kitchn had also previously covered a different Jimmy Dean product: contributor Kate found the brand’s Sausage, Egg and Cheese Biscuit a close match for McDonald’s biscuit sandwich. That earlier comparison concerned a biscuit sandwich, not the English muffin version reviewed by Domrongchai. In the current test, the reviewer’s choice was the English Muffin Egg and Cheese, which she said most closely matched the Egg McMuffin.
““The Jimmy Dean English Muffin Egg and Cheese was the closest to my favorite McDonald’s one.””
— Ali Domrongchai, The Kitchn associate editor
best frozen English muffin breakfast sandwiches
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Limits of the Taste Test
The supplied report does not identify all five brands and 12 products, describe a blind-testing process, or provide a scoring method. It also does not state how many times each sandwich was tasted or whether another reviewer independently assessed the results. The selection is therefore best read as one editor’s informal product review, not a representative consumer survey.
The article gives prices from the time of publication but does not specify the stores or locations where they were found. Current prices and availability may differ. It also does not provide nutrition details or a direct comparison of preparation time and serving size. The headline frames the test around eating frozen sandwiches every day for a week; the supplied account confirms a weeklong tasting of a dozen sandwiches, but does not say that the same sandwich was eaten every day.
frozen breakfast sandwiches comparison
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Check Local Prices and Labels
The Kitchn report does not announce a follow-up test or a further publication date. Readers considering the product can compare local package prices and check the ingredient and nutrition labels, since the reviewed Jimmy Dean sandwich differs from McDonald’s in its sausage and egg. The article’s result remains a recommendation based on Domrongchai’s reported taste test; no broader testing or updated price check is provided in the source material.
cheaper breakfast sandwich options
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
Which frozen sandwich did The Kitchn reviewer prefer?
Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese was Domrongchai’s preferred match for a McDonald’s Egg McMuffin among the 12 sandwiches she tasted.
How much did the sandwiches cost in the report?
Domrongchai reported paying $8 for a four-pack of Jimmy Dean sandwiches, or $2 each at that package price, and $4.89 for one McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. The report notes that its prices were accurate when published; local prices may vary.
Are the Jimmy Dean and McDonald’s sandwiches identical?
No. The report says both include an English muffin, egg, cheddar and sausage, but Jimmy Dean’s sausage includes chicken and its egg is a scrambled disk. McDonald’s uses a whole egg with a hard yolk.
Was this a formal or blind taste test?
The supplied article describes a one-week tasting by one reviewer but does not report a blind-testing method, scoring system or independent panel. Its winner reflects Domrongchai’s personal assessment.
Did the report compare nutrition?
No nutrition comparison is included in the supplied material. Readers who want to compare dietary details should check the current product labels and restaurant information.
Source: rss
NFL season / tailgating Picks
team gear
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
