TL;DR
The Kitchn asked three chefs how to make flaky pie crust, and all three emphasized keeping the ingredients and tools cold. Their other advice includes using ice water sparingly, avoiding overwork and chilling the dough for at least two hours; they differed on which fats to use.
Three chefs interviewed by The Kitchn agreed that keeping pie-dough ingredients and tools cold is the most important step for a flaky crust. Their advice matters to home bakers heading into the holiday pie season, when a warm or overworked dough can lose the butter pockets that help create flaky layers.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The chefs were Brian Boldt, executive chef at Kroger; Bryan Ford, chef and co-founder of Diljān Bakery; and John Bard, executive pastry chef at The Lake House on Canandaigua. Each stressed temperature control, including keeping butter cold and using ice water. Boldt said he returns his bowl to the refrigerator if the fat begins to soften, while Bard advised adding only enough cold water to make the dough come together.
Ford explained that cold butter leaves small pockets in the dough. In the oven, he said, those pockets create steam and contribute to flaky layers. The chefs also cautioned against mixing until the dough looks smooth: Ford said visible butter pieces are useful, while Boldt warned that overworking can develop gluten and produce a tougher, denser crust.
Their methods and fat preferences were not identical. Ford and Bard favor all-butter crusts, while Boldt combines butter with lard or shortening. The chefs also recommend chilling the dough before rolling it; the report gives at least two hours as a suggested rest, with overnight chilling as another option. Bard and Ford favor weighing ingredients, and Ford recommends using a bench scraper to handle dough without warming it with hands.
Cold Dough Shapes Flaky Layers
The shared advice gives home bakers a practical starting point: temperature control is a more consistent point of agreement than the choice between butter, shortening or lard. Keeping fat solid while mixing and rolling helps preserve the pieces that the chefs associate with flakiness. It also gives bakers a useful troubleshooting step: if dough softens or becomes difficult to handle, chill it rather than adding more flour or continuing to work it.
The guidance is not a guarantee that every crust will turn out the same. Flour, butter, technique and oven conditions can all affect the result, and the supplied report does not provide a controlled recipe test comparing the chefs’ methods. Still, the chefs’ agreement offers a clear technique to try without requiring specialized equipment: start cold, add water cautiously and stop mixing once the dough can be pressed together.
Products Worth Considering

Weber Q 1400 Portable Electric Grill, Gray

De'Longhi Magnifica Evo Fully Automatic Espresso Machine with Milk Frother, Silver

Instant Pot Vortex Plus 6-Quart Air Fryer
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Where the Chefs Differ
The Kitchn report was framed around the approach of Thanksgiving, which it described as a peak period for pie baking. It asked the three professionals for ways to make homemade crust reliably flaky, rather than reporting a new recipe, product launch or formal test. Its central finding is the chefs’ shared temperature advice, alongside several practical tips drawn from their own kitchen methods.
On fats, the chefs did not reach a single preference. Ford said butter provides flavor and richness, and Bard also prefers an all-butter crust. Boldt uses butter with lard or shortening, saying the fats can contribute different qualities to texture and structure. Bard said a dough can be made with any one of those fats or a mixture. The report therefore supports the cold-fat rule as common advice, not a consensus on one ideal recipe.
“Cold butter doesn’t melt as quickly as the room temperature stuff.”
— Bryan Ford, chef and co-founder of Diljān Bakery, as quoted by The Kitchn
No Single Fat Wins
The report does not identify a single best fat or give a standardized recipe tested by all three chefs. Their preferences vary, and the supplied material does not specify exact ingredient ratios, flour types, oven temperatures or a method for measuring which crust is flakiest. The source excerpt also ends as it begins a section on adding egg, vinegar or sugar, so it does not provide the chefs’ full advice on those ingredients.
Although the report calls cold ingredients and tools the chefs’ common rule, it does not describe a controlled comparison of warm and cold dough. The practical recommendations are professional opinions attributed to the chefs, not a claim that temperature alone determines the outcome.
Try the Method at Home
The report gives no scheduled follow-up or further testing. For bakers applying the advice, the next steps are to chill the fat and bowl, use ice water sparingly, leave some butter pieces visible and refrigerate the dough for at least two hours before rolling. Ford also suggests returning dough to the refrigerator if it tears, shrinks or resists rolling. Those steps reflect the chefs’ recommendations; readers should still follow a chosen recipe for ingredient amounts and baking instructions.
Key Questions
What was the chefs’ main shared rule for flaky pie crust?
All three chefs told The Kitchn to keep the ingredients and tools cold, especially the butter and water.
Do all three chefs recommend an all-butter crust?
No. Ford and Bard prefer all butter, while Boldt uses butter with lard or shortening. The chefs agreed on keeping the fat cold, not on one fat combination.
How long should pie dough rest before rolling?
The report says the chefs recommend chilling dough for at least two hours; overnight is another option.
Why should pie dough not be overmixed?
Boldt said overworking can develop gluten and make the crust tough or dense. Ford said pieces of butter should remain visible in the dough.
Source: thekitchn.com
